The Supreme Court says yes — but only in rare and compelling cases.
In National Projects Construction Corporation Ltd. v. Ishvakoo (India) Pvt. Ltd. (2026 INSC 828), a Bench of Justices K.V. Viswanathan and Alok Aradhe answered it.
The Facts:
– A ₹3.5 crore mobilisation advance was secured by bank guarantees.
– A 2005 Delhi High Court order kept them alive, allowing encashment only if the Award required the claimant to pay the employer.
– The claimant could not keep them alive; the employer encashed them in 2017, before the Award.
– The 2017 Award dismissed the claimant’s claims. No counter-claim was filed, and the discharge of the guarantees was never decided.
– Post-Award, the losing claimant sought the money back under Section 9 pending Section 34; the High Court ordered a ₹3.5 crore deposit.
The Court’s answer — YES, but at a higher threshold. Relying on Home Care Retail Marts and Essar House, it held Section 9 is not reserved for winners: denying it could leave a losing party remediless. Prima facie case, balance of convenience and irreparable harm still govern, but the bar is higher and relief follows only in rare and compelling cases.
Why this qualified: no counter-claim; prima facie, no finding that the mobilisation advance went unutilised; and the Arbitrator appeared unaware the guarantees were already encashed. Retention pending Section 34, the Court agreed, would unjustly enrich the employer; the appeal was dismissed.
The observations were confined to Section 9; Section 34 will be decided on its own merits.
Takeaway: an adverse award raises the bar for Section 9 relief; it does not close the remedy.
Judgment: https://lnkd.in/gbtPF2-N
Content shared for general information only; not legal advice or solicitation.
#GCJuris #Arbitration #ArbitrationLaw #Section9 #Section34 #InterimRelief #SupremeCourtOfIndia #LegalUpdate


